Hills like white elephant Essay

Hills like white colored elephant

" Hills Just like White Elephants": The Jilting of Lure

Hashmi, Nilofer.

The Tolstoy Review, Amount 23, Best, Fall the year 2003, pp. 72-83 (Article)

Printed by School of Idaho Department of English

DOI: 10. 1353/hem. 2004. 0009

For additional information regarding this article


Access Provided by Chulalongkorn College or university at 11/21/11 7: 26AM GMT

" hills like white elephants”:

T l e l i luxury touring i in g of j we g

nilofer hashmi

Atlanta Southern College or university

critics grappling with Ernest Hemingway's hauntingly enigmatic " Hills Just like White Elephants” have failed to reach a consensus regarding the ending of the storyline. 1 Just about all agree, however , that regardless of what actually occurs, the existing relationship between the American and the girl will weaken, or terminate. Three different scenarios have been completely seriously considered: the woman will have the abortion (albeit reluctantly) and stay with the person; the girl will have the abortion and keep the man; or, the girl won't have the abortion, having won the man over to her point of view. Nevertheless , there is solid support in the narrative for a fourth outcome that fits in with the dark overall prognosis presented in other educational interpretations: the girl will indeed have the child killingilligal baby killing, expecting in this manner to stay upon with the person, but following your operation has become performed, he can abandon her. Various mental and non-verbal indications present in the story support this meaning of the narrative, as does the very symbolism from the title by itself. Among the distinct, strongly contended readings in the story's closing suggested by various college students is the discharge, alluded to above, that the girl could have the illigal baby killing but will then simply leave the American. This outcome is usually visualized by simply Howard Hannum: She has made a decision to have the child killingilligal baby killing but not in order to resume her life while using American. Which is not so much a question of her having the courage to leave him, after the abortion, as it is a clear case of her being unable to tolerate him—of her having left him in her wake. (53)

23, NUMBER 1, FALL 2003. Copyright В© the year 2003 The Ernest

Hemingway Base. Published by University of Idaho Press, Moscow, Florida.


n my spouse and i l o f e r

they would a t h meters i



This is a encomiable reading. The conversation between your two seems to indicate there is little love between them. As a result the girl, who have now wants more than a relationship based on love-making and alcohol, would have zero reason to stay on with all the man. Nevertheless , one or two bothersome details are not able to fit into this scenario: how come the girl laugh at the person, whom your woman supposedly cannot tolerate, if he tells her he had better move the plastic bags? Why does the lady urge the man to come back so they can finish the drink collectively? And how come she laugh at him again when he returns after placing all their bags nearer to the point of departure? A mere smile probably would not be sufficient reason to cast uncertainty on an interpretation in the case of many writers. Nevertheless this copy writer is Tolstoy.

Turning to another interpretation, all of us find an innovative and difficult view of the story's finishing offered by Stanley Renner through his browsing of what he thinks a key sentence in your essay in the story. When the woman serving beverages informs the couple of the imminent arrival in the train, the person picks up the plastic bags to carry them to " lack of of the station”(CSS 214). Fixing great significance to the word " different, ” Hammer (umgangssprachlich) argues: " What the girl's outbursts make clear to the American is merely how solid her resistance from having an abortion is usually. ” Because of this realization, plus the girl's " overpowering unwillingness, ” Hammer (umgangssprachlich) contends, the person gives in and provides the bags to the " other” side, which in turn he perceives as as a symbol of the ladies side with the issue (34). 2 Relating to this model, the girl laughs because the gentleman has capitulated, and this wounderful woman has triumphed. Hence, in Renner's...